STATEMENT ON PROPOSED BLASPHEMY LEGISLATION by The Humanist Association of Ireland

The Humanist Association of Ireland has a principled objection to any attempt to introduce the crime of blasphemy into legislation. The proposed legislation to criminalise blasphemy amounts to a threat to free speech and a threat to religious freedom. No two religions agree on every theological point of view and adherents of each must be free to express those views even if they are considered blasphemous by the adherents of a different religion. In fact one person's 'blasphemy' is another's sincere belief. In addition Humanists and others must be free to question all religious beliefs.  In a free society, freedom of expression including criticism of ideas and beliefs is one of the most basic and cherished rights and the free exchange of ideas is a fundamental element in human development.   While we support the freedom of religion and conscience, no religious or philosophical beliefs should be protected from vigorous criticism and challenge.

Religious beliefs should enjoy no extra protection compared with non-religious beliefs. Any legislation which tends to inhibit or prevent the full and critical discussion of ideas and beliefs in the free market place of ideas is incompatible with the principles of a modern democratic republic.

It may occur that some individuals will take offence at critical or contradictory evidence of dearly held beliefs. But the nature of debate on any issue of controversy carries that possibility. Thus we distinguish between critisising ideas and beliefs in contrast with critisising individuals for holding those beliefs.  Currently there are adequate laws in place to protect individuals from libelous attacks.

This Association calls on the Minister to reconsider his proposal to make blasphemy a crime as it could imperil the right to free speech for all its citizens.

Dick Spicer Chair HAI